Big Guy
| # | Song Title | Artist |
| 15 | I'm Not Too Old for You | Root Boy Slim |
| 14 | New Kind of Freedom | Nils Lofgren |
| 13 | Same Old Tears on a New Background | Stephen Bishop |
| 12 | Four and Twenty | CSNY |
| 11 | My Old School | Steely Dan |
| 10 | Same Old Song and Dance | Aerosmith |
| 9 | Young Americans | David Bowie |
| 8 | Fairytale of New York | The Pogues |
| 7 | Wives Don't Like Old Girlfriends | Suzy Bogguss |
| 6 | Good Old Fashioned Lover Boy | Queen |
| 5 | So Young | The Rolling Stones |
| 4 | Old Laughing Lady | Neil Young |
| 3 | New Coat of Paint | Tom Waits |
| 2 | New Tune | James Taylor |
| 1 | New Day Yesterday | Jethro Tull |
BLOB
| # | Song Title | Artist |
| 16 | Skating Away on the Thin Ice of a New Day | Jethro Tull |
| 15 | Same Old Song and Dance | Aerosmith |
| 14 | Straw Hat and Old Dirty Hank | Barenaked Ladies |
| 13 | Brand New Key | Melanie |
| 12 | Old Guitar | John Denver |
| 11 | Old Brown Shoe | The Beatles |
| 10 | New Sensation | INXS |
| 9 | Young Americans | David Bowie |
| 8 | Wild Heart of the Young | Karla Bonoff |
| 7 | Hello, Old Friend | Eric Clapton |
| 6 | Only the Good Die Young | Billy Joel |
| 5 | Old-fashioned Love Song | Three Dog Night |
| 4 | Old Days | Chicago |
| 3 | New Kid in Town | Eagles |
| 2 | Grow Old with Me | John Lennon |
| 1 | Same Old Lang Syne | Dan Fogelberg |
Bones
Craigar
| # | Song Title | Artist |
| 13 | Smashing Young Man | Collective Soul |
| 12 | Old LA Tonight (video: How?) | Ozzy Osbourne |
| 11 | Only the Young | Journey |
| 10 | City of New Orleans | Arlo Guthrie |
| 9 | Only Sixteen | Dr. Hook |
| 8 | New York Minute | Don Henley |
| 7 | Eighteen | Alice Cooper |
| 6 | New Year's Day | U2 |
| 5 | Edge of Seventeen | Stevie Nicks |
| 4 | Same Old Lang Syne | Dan Fogelberg |
| 3 | Fooling Yourself (Angry Young Man) | Styx |
| 2 | Old-fashioned Love Song | Three Dog Night |
| 1 | New Kid in Town | Eagles |
Jeffro
| # | Song Title | Artist |
| 12 | Little Old Wine Drinker Me | Dean Martin |
| 11 | New York Minute | Don Henley |
| 10 | New Year's Day | Carolyn Arends |
| 9 | Youngblood | Bad Company |
| 8 | That Ol' Door (video: I Couldn't Leave You If I Tried) | Rodney Crowell |
| 7 | Old Man and Me | Hootie & The Blowfish |
| 6 | This Old House | CSNY |
| 5 | Too Old to Rock 'n' Roll, Too Young to Die | Jethro Tull |
| 4 | Same Old Lang Syne | Dan Fogelberg |
| 3 | New Favorite | Alison Krauss & Union Station |
| 2 | New York City Serenade | Bruce Springsteen |
| 1 | New Kid in Town | Eagles |
Johnno
Markus
| # | Song Title | Artist |
| 15 | Old Blue Chair | Kenny Chesney |
| 14 | We Die Young | Alice in Chains |
| 13 | Old Man | Neil Young |
| 12 | My Old School | Steely Dan |
| 11 | Except the New Girl | Chris Isaak |
| 10 | So Young | The Corrs |
| 9 | Sending the Old Man Home (video: Come Monday) | Jimmy Buffett |
| 8 | New Connection (video: Beer Run) | Todd Snider |
| 7 | My Old Friend | John Hiatt |
| 6 | Young Lust | Pink Floyd |
| 5 | Old Folks Boogie | Little Feat |
| 4 | Old Ghosts | Jethro Tull |
| 3 | Never Die Young | James Taylor |
| 2 | Same Old Song and Dance | Aerosmith |
| 1 | New Kid in Town | Eagles |